|
Health System Fails Kids’ Mental
Health
By Rick Nauert, Ph.D.
According to experts, an estimated
15 million American children are diagnosed with a mental disorder,
but only about a quarter of them are getting appropriate treatment
based on scientific evidence.
|
|
Furthermore,
many more children are at risk of developing behavioral
disorders.
Sadly, the problem is only
going to get worse unless the health care system changes how
it delivers services, finds a task force of the American
Psychological Association.
A report released Wednesday
by APA’s Presidential Task Force on Evidence-Based Practice
with Children and Adolescents recommends dissemination of
evidence-based practice approaches – treatments that are
based on scientific evidence along with clinical expertise
while taking into account patient characteristics, culture
and preferences – as a way to ensure that children and
adolescents with mental health |
|
problems receive the best
available care.
“The care should
include prevention, early intervention, targeted
treatments for particular disorders, an understanding of
developmental processes and continuity of care,” said
task force chair Anne E. Kazak, PhD, ABPP. |
“Furthermore, treatments should be
accessible regardless of age, gender, sexual orientation,
disability, race, ethnicity and culture. Lastly, evidence-based
practice should be cross-disciplinary and include collaborations
with families, schools, practitioners and researchers from various
health fields.”
These treatments and services need
to reach youth from all different cultures, geographic regions and
socioeconomic groups to prevent further escalation of the problem,
said Kazak.
“This is especially true for
low-income youth, for youth in the juvenile justice and child
welfare systems, ethnic minority youth, and those with drug/alcohol
problems.”
The report of the seven-member task
force builds on and extends the work of a 2005 Presidential Task
Force on Evidence-Based Practice.
The current task force
conceptualized evidence-based care for children and adolescents,
including those at risk for as well as those diagnosed with a mental
disorder, across a number of settings. Settings included families,
schools, health care systems, and the juvenile justice system.
The task force members cite several
examples of evidence-based practice’s effectiveness in treating
ethnic minority youth with anxiety-related problems, ADHD,
depression, conduct problems, substance use problems and other
trauma-related syndromes.
These treatments were effective,
according to the report, because practitioners were culturally
responsive to their clients and were able to treat them long enough
for them to experience the benefits. There is a high dropout rate
for clinicians who are not culturally sensitive to their ethnic
minority clients, the report found.
Several reviews and meta-analyses
examined in the report also showed the benefits of using empirically
tested treatment programs for both children and their parents in
dealing with autism, eating problems and disorders, depression,
phobias and anxiety disorders, obsessive-compulsive disorder, trauma
and substance abuse.
The task force concluded that
evidence-based practice is essential for addressing the needs of
children and adolescents with myriad mental health problems.
The report recommends ways for
psychologists to build relationships with health and educational
institutions to generate more research in this area and transfer it
into clinical practice. Further, the report offers ways to educate
and train practitioners delivering this type of care and suggestions
for changing policies so evidence-based care will be financially
feasible and available to those who need it.
The following are some of the
specific recommendations by the task force.
Research
- Increase research funding to
develop and deliver evidence-based practice to children in
different settings
- Establish multidisciplinary
coalitions to provide guidance on funding mechanisms for
development and dissemination of evidence-based practice for
children and adolescents
Education and Training
- Develop interdisciplinary
Web-based training on core areas of evidence-based practice that
include social work, education, pediatrics and psychiatry
- Develop accessible Web-based
interactive system to allow stakeholders – state psychological
associations, state directors of children’s mental health
services, universities, mental health agencies, practitioners
and families with youth needing treatment – to share information
about using evidence-based practice in different settings
- Increase evidence-based
practice for children and adolescents in graduate and
post-graduate training programs and develop means for evaluating
EBP training
- Include evidence-based
practice in continuing education to increase likelihood that
frontline professionals have training opportunities
- Encourage cross-disciplinary,
culturally diverse training in an international framework to
encourage attention to evidence-based practice
Practice and Policy
- Identify appropriate funding
levels so adequate coverage for evidence-based practice is
secured for children and adolescents
- Develop policies that promote
access to evidence-based practice for children and families,
especially for underserved populations, such as ethnic minority
children, pre-adolescents, children with multiple health and
substance abuse problems and those with disabilities.
Additionally, children who are in the child welfare and juvenile
justice system and those in homeless shelters also need access
to evidence-based interventions.
- Eliminate barriers to
evidence-based practice for children and adolescents in the
private sector and at the state and federal level as well as in
regulatory and policy initiatives.
- Establish a
cross-disciplinary, multi-agency task force to examine the
barriers to evidence-based practice for children and adolescents
-- Courtesy
of Psychcentral.com
Click
Here To Have Your Say On This Story
Brudirect.com News
|